And it isn't so much that this often-messy album, the 10-member collective's third, strays too far from Wu's home ground. It doesn't. And that's the main problem. Producer RZA piles on the creepy minor-chord hymns, and the group's core rappers -- Raekwon and Method Man -- toss off some good lines. But you've heard it all before. Wu's spotty 1993 debut, Enter the Wu-Tang (36 Chambers), set up the N.Y.C. crew as a forcefully individual outfit capable of working surprisingly well together. Wu-Tang Forever allowed the band and its members to play out for more than two hours. The W grinds in place, never quite bolstering the collective authority. Tracks for the album were started in Los Angeles, but RZA eventually took the entire project back to his basement studio in Staten Island. Perhaps the pressure to deliver got to him. There are fleeting moments of brilliance: "Protect Ya Neck (The Jump Off)" is classic Wu style, all skulking and menacing beats with a nod to Public Enemy, and the funky "Gravel Pit" is the most tuneful thing they've ever done. Alas, the rest is mostly just a hearty, heaping serving of leftovers.
Subscribe now to get the latest news delivered right to your inbox.