September 21, 2022

Rewind: Scene's Best of Cleveland Restaurant Winners From the Year 2000


How were we dining as a city in the year 2000?

Twenty-two years is a long time. It's an even longer period of time when you're discussing restaurants and dining trends, which seem to evolve faster with each passing year. In light of this year’s Best of Cleveland awards, we thought it would be fun to look back at some of the winners from 2000.

This was a time of considerable upheaval in the restaurant world, which up to then had been dominated by large, lumbering establishments. When it came to independent fine-dining eateries, the selection was embarrassingly limited. To celebrate that special occasion, you could book a seat at Johnny’s Bar, Baricelli Inn, Blue Point Grille, Sans Souci or Giovanni’s.

For something a little more hip, a diner would hit up places like Flying Fig, Parker’s, Sergio’s, Moxie, Mojo or Lola. If you want to pinpoint the birth of the celebrity chef era in Cleveland, you would look to this time period. While relatively unknown at the time, chefs like Karen Small, Marlin Kaplan, Sergio Abramof, Parker Bosley, Michael Herschman and Michael Symon were just beginning to ignite the local food scene. Chef Doug Katz would not leave Moxie to open Fire for another year. Take these chefs out of the equation and the Cleveland restaurant scene of today looks very, very different.

The 2000 Best of Cleveland awards managed to catch some – but far from all – of these rising star chefs. Lola Bistro rightly claimed the Best Restaurant award, while Flying Fig was singled out for its “fabulous food” and “Greenwich Village on the Lake” vibe. That year’s Best New Chef award went to Steve Parris, who would have gotten my vote as well. His work at the Fulton Bar and Grill helped transform Ohio City into the food mecca it is today. Parris transitioned out of restaurant kitchens, but that space is now home to Momocho.

The Best New Restaurant award in 2000 went to Mise, a sound decision given that Lakewood eatery’s undeniable cool factor. In the kitchen, chef Jeff Uniatowski wowed diners with edgy-at-the-time small plates, martinis and French press coffee. Mise’s relatively short lifespan also gave rise to the “cursed location” myth. Before Mise opened, the space was home to Jeso, La Pomme and Wilshire Grill. After it closed, that property hosted Giovanna’s, Velocity American Bistro and Clifton Martini and Wine Bar.

Looking back to the 2000 winner for Best Dessert we find an absolute gem of a restaurant. Battuto, operated by Giovanna Mingroni and Mark Daverio, was Little Italy’s shining star bistro for seven years, until the recession snuffed out the flame.

Some things never change, like Best Corned Beef Sandwich (Slyman’s), Best Steakhouse (Hyde Park), Best Sushi (Shuhei), Best Wine List (Chez Francois), Best Tabletop Adventure (Empress Taytu), Best Bar Food (Lava Lounge) and Best Beer Views (Major Hoopples).

Speaking of beer: If you wanted to sip a local beer other than Great Lakes back then, your choices were limited to Rock Bottom, Diamond Back, Rocky River and Crooked River, whose ESB walked away with honors in 2000 for Best Local Beer.

We take comfort food on menus for granted these days, but there was a time when the return to these sort of throwback dishes was a wholly new concept. The trend started in the wake of 9/11 and continues to enjoy airtime today. In 2000, the Best Comfort Food, according to Scene, was found at the Yorkville Café, a savvy neighborhood spot in Cleveland Heights. After the Yorkville closed, the building became home to Lopez Bar & Grille, the second iteration of Lopez y Gonzalez, and now the second iteration of Mojo.

In 2000, the staff of this magazine selected Hunan of Solon as the winner for Best Chinese Comfort Food. Bo Loong, Li Wah, Pearl of the Orient, Peking Gourmet and Sun Luck Garden apparently all failed to make the cut.

It’s funny to think about how few patios Cleveland had even 10 years ago, let alone 22. Today, it’s a challenge to come up with a handful of restaurants with no outdoor seating. (In 2000, Baricelli Inn walked home with the trophy.)

So what will be eating in 2044? In addition to tacos, hot chicken, BBQ and wood-fired pizza, it's anybody's guess.

Check out all the winners as they appeared in the Best of Cleveland 2000 issue below.
Scroll down to view images

Join the Cleveland Scene Press Club

At a time when local-based reporting is critical, support from our readers is essential to our future. Join the Cleveland Scene Press Club for as little as $5 a month

Rewind: Scene's Best of Cleveland Restaurant Winners From the Year 2000
Scene
Rewind: Scene's Best of Cleveland Restaurant Winners From the Year 2000
Scene
Rewind: Scene's Best of Cleveland Restaurant Winners From the Year 2000
Scene
Rewind: Scene's Best of Cleveland Restaurant Winners From the Year 2000
Scene
Rewind: Scene's Best of Cleveland Restaurant Winners From the Year 2000
Scene
Rewind: Scene's Best of Cleveland Restaurant Winners From the Year 2000
Scene
Rewind: Scene's Best of Cleveland Restaurant Winners From the Year 2000
Scene
Rewind: Scene's Best of Cleveland Restaurant Winners From the Year 2000
Scene
Rewind: Scene's Best of Cleveland Restaurant Winners From the Year 2000
Scene
Rewind: Scene's Best of Cleveland Restaurant Winners From the Year 2000
Scene