Touch My Heart: A Tribute to Johnny Paycheck is that rare beast, a tribute compilation without a single misstep. Producer Robbie Fulks pulled in Paycheck peers George Jones and Johnny Bush; younger country artists Jim Lauderdale and Dallas Wayne; pop legends Al Anderson, Marshall Crenshaw, and Jeff Tweedy; bluegrass stars Billy Yates and Larry Cordle; and alt-country heroes Neko Case, Bobby Bare Jr., and Mike Ireland, to name a few.
The two most amazing songs on an album with no wrong turns come from different sides of the musical fence. Dallas Wayne fits perfectly in the Paycheck tradition of pure honky-tonk. His version of "I Did the Right Thing" is chilling, capturing all the pain of a man who returns to his wife after an affair because it is what society expects of him. Two songs later, Mavis Staples devastates the listener with "Touch My Heart," a Paycheck original that almost certainly didn't sound quite so bluesy before she got to it. When you hear the sorrow that permeates this track, mixed with the belief that this sorrow makes life seem worthwhile, you'll know immediately why they named the album after it.