Support Local Journalism. Join the Cleveland Scene Press Club.

Wing and a Prayer 

Porcupine Tree strives to take prog rock back into the mainstream.

Porcupine Tree began as a fake band with an invented - discography and no music.
  • Porcupine Tree began as a fake band with an invented discography and no music.
"There's two things I want to avoid more than anything else," says Porcupine Tree founder-leader Steven Wilson. "One is sounding like other bands, and the other is repeating myself. So in some respects, they become two of the most important influences on a project -- albeit in an extremely negative way. A lot of stuff gets ditched because it's derivative or it sounds like something we've played before. The days are long gone when I would be listening to an album and say, 'I really must do something like that.'"

If all that's true (and, if nothing else, Wilson probably believes it is), then why does Porcupine Tree sound so entrenched in the recent past? The first thing one notices about the band's latest album, Deadwing, is how deeply indebted it is to the sounds of the early- to mid-'90s, when bands like Soundgarden and Jane's Addiction were competing for the airwaves with rockers of a previous generation. The opening title cut floats by with an arcing guitar solo and subdued vocal presence that's pure post-Roger Waters Pink Floyd. This is followed by "Shallow," the album's first single, which is built around a riff that the Stone Temple Pilots would have killed for. And the way "Mellotron Scratch" goes from strummed acoustic guitar to Big Bad Riff is total post-grunge arena rock -- the kind of stuff every also-ran from Candlebox to Bush traded in.

This sort of pastiche persists throughout the disc, with the piano-driven "Lazarus" sounding like a mix of Coldplay and the mostly forgotten psychedelic popsters of Jellyfish. (Wilson says that he's heard of the band, but has never actually heard its music -- he cites Skylarking-era XTC as a big influence, though.) The album's next-to-last track, "Glass Arm Shattering," successfully struggles out from under its OK Computer-era Radiohead feel by adding "sha-la-la" background vocals. But make no mistake, Deadwing's all-over-the-place effect doesn't make it a bad album -- it's a very good, albeit disjointed record from a band that's made a name for itself by both confounding and delighting fans of progressive rock for more than a decade.

Deadwing's scattershot approach isn't helped by the fact that Porcupine Tree hasn't always been a band. The group started out as a project, entirely the vision of guitarist-singer Wilson. To begin with, all he had was the name; he invented a history and discography for a fictitious band before deciding that maybe he should actually record some music. Porcupine Tree's early records bound it to the U.K.'s psychedelic scene, where the band found itself lumped in with dirty hippies like the European phenom Ozric Tentacles.

The broad, shape-shifting Porcupine Tree aesthetic has always incorporated whatever sounds Wilson was interested in at the moment -- the almost trance-techno elements on the Orblike Voyage 34 are one example, but even that disc looked backward, sampling dialogue from a 1960s album about LSD use. The band's last three records have been steps toward embracing the music of the present day: Porcupine Tree, circa 2005, makes a very accessible blend of prog and hard-alternative rock. Sometimes almost cartoonishly rifftastic, but also expansively melodic, Deadwing is the apotheosis of this trend in the group's sound, and it brands Porcupine Tree as a maker of intricate, high-quality rock.

If you believe Steven Wilson, though, the transition to an overtly radio-friendly big-rock sound is deliberate, from an artistic standpoint -- and totally accidental, from a commercial point of view.

"Nothing in this band is ever conscious," he says emphatically. "We've always made music very much for ourselves, and anything that's happened in terms of attracting a fan base has been coincidental. Every album is an evolution in the band's sound, and this one is no exception. But around three albums ago, I started to get more interested in songwriting again, and less interested in long guitar solos and instrumental blowouts. I guess that was just a consequence of my listening diet. I got more into the idea of writing great songs, and so that became a part of the band's sound. And then a couple of albums ago, I got really into heavy death-metal stuff, so that began to creep more into the band's sound as well."

That side trip into metal -- specifically, Wilson's friendship and collaboration with Swedish art-thrash master Opeth -- is one of the more interesting aspects of the Porcupine Tree saga. Wilson produced Opeth's last three albums and greatly regrets that scheduling conflicts prevented him from working on the band's upcoming disc. By getting behind the board, he assisted Opeth leader Mikael Akerfeldt in achieving his dream of a symphonic-rock sound in a metal context. In return, Wilson was turned on to the virtues of aggression, which manifests itself in Deadwing's more savage passages. (Akerfeldt contributes a guitar solo to "Arriving Somewhere but Not Here" on Deadwing and sings harmony vocals on two other tracks.) While nothing on the disc approaches the brutality of Opeth's Deliverance, there is certainly a joy in the power and glory of the riff that would surprise anyone who'd heard an early Porcupine Tree release before picking up the new one.

With all this in mind, it's easy to give Wilson the benefit of the doubt when he describes his band's career arc as nothing but "a reflection of my own musical tastes and my own experiences." He seems genuinely surprised, at times, at how far he's taken Porcupine Tree. "Luckily, it's gone in the right direction, in the sense that more people seem to like it, rather than less," he says. "But it could easily have gone the other direction."

We welcome readers to submit letters regarding articles and content in Cleveland Scene. Letters should be a minimum of 150 words, refer to content that has appeared on Cleveland Scene, and must include the writer's full name, address, and phone number for verification purposes. No attachments will be considered. Writers of letters selected for publication will be notified via email. Letters may be edited and shortened for space.

Email us at

Support Local Journalism.
Join the Cleveland Scene Press Club

Local journalism is information. Information is power. And we believe everyone deserves access to accurate independent coverage of their community and state. Our readers helped us continue this coverage in 2020, and we are so grateful for the support.

Help us keep this coverage going in 2021. Whether it's a one-time acknowledgement of this article or an ongoing membership pledge, your support goes to local-based reporting from our small but mighty team.

Join the Cleveland Scene Press Club for as little as $5 a month.

More by Phil Freeman

Read the Digital Print Issue

January 5, 2022

View more issues

Most Popular

No recently-read stories.

Visit the archives…


Never miss a beat

Sign Up Now

Subscribe now to get the latest news delivered right to your inbox.


Staff Pick Events

  • Dustin Nickerson @ Hilarities Comedy Club

    • Thu., Jan. 20
  • Clayton English @ Hilarities Comedy Club

    • Fri., Jan. 21
  • Windborne's the Music of Queen @ State Theatre

    • Fri., Jan. 21

© 2022 Cleveland Scene: 737 Bolivar Rd., Suite 4100, Cleveland, OH 44115, (216) 505-8199
Logos and trademarks on this site are property of their respective owners.

Website powered by Foundation