The second thing that makes this collection notable is the programming. The project was produced by Coltrane's son Ravi, who decided to break up the material along thematic lines, with one disc focusing on 'Trane's approach to harmony and melody, another on his rhythmic conception in general, and a third on the spectacular fireworks created with master drummer Elvin Jones. The last CD consists of live recordings. Of course, these categories overlap, but the programming works because the choices are good. Obvious picks like "My Favorite Things" and "Naima" are here, but so are neglected classics like "Your Lady" and "Crescent." A better gift for a young musician would be hard to imagine.
Charles Lloyd's Lift Every Voice stems from his feelings about the events of September 11. Most of the music is slow and meditative, featuring folk hymns such as "Amazing Grace" and "Deep River," as well as originals and Billy Strayhorn's auto-requiem "Bloodcount." Lloyd's debt to Coltrane is apparent here, but of course, so is his originality. The supporting cast includes pianist Geri Allen and several musicians who have been working with Lloyd in recent years. An impressive and heartfelt offering from this ever-evolving musician.