To the 5 Boroughs, released in 2004, was an exercise in reminiscence masquerading as a nod to current events -- post-September 11 New Yorkers hailing the city of their youth. The Mix-Up, in contrast, is an admission of obsolescence. Not that it's bad. Tossed off, underdone, monotonous, unfinished, and redundant -- maybe. But not bad.
Think back to "Lighten Up" and "Groove Holmes," the lounge instrumentals on Check Your Head. Now remove the dub and the samples, but leave the low-key vamps, Fender Rhodes, crispy 4/4 snares, congas, vintage distortion, and Metered shuffle. "Off the Grid" even crams in handclaps, a meandering guitar solo, and an ethereal keyboard. But it stands out only because it doesn't repeat incessantly.
Given that the Beastie Boys made an art of plundering everything they could get their hands on, what's left but the history they once made?