Health, Lies and Videotape

Despite a fast and bold start out of the gate, it looks like whatever health-care reform plan President Obama passes will be a far cry from his original idea: publicly funded health care for all who want it. Obama's obsession with bipartisanship, the political pressure of the insurance and pharmaceutical industries, and in no small part, the borderline violent dissent at public forums has turned "change we can believe in" into "I can't believe you're changing."

Unlike bottom-up organizations like that take no corporate donations, most of the organizations behind the right-wing "grassroots" movement to derail reform are directly or indirectly related to the guys poised to lose big bucks if Obama's plan passes. Take, for example, FreedomWorks, headed by former Republican House Majority Leader Dick Armey of Texas. Until August 14, Armey was senior policy advisor for the lobbying firm DLA Piper, which, according to, has received $830,000 this year from big-pharma corporation the Medicines Co. In 2008, it received $1.5 million.

Like many of his colleagues in the public-opinion trenches, Armey is a master of "throw the stone, hide the hand." Confronted by Rachel Maddow on Meet the Press about a video produced by a tea-party organization affiliated with FreedomWorks, in which townhall-meeting violence is praised and encouraged, Armey laughed it off as a case of blaming FreedomWorks for others' misdeeds.

"[The Tea Party movement] is an enormously impressive uprising across the country, loosely affiliated people," he said. "These things happen ... [and] people get blamed for what other people do."

"Other people" like Heather Blish, from Green Bay, Wisconsin. At an August 6 townhall meeting, Blish introduced herself as just "a mom from a few blocks away ... not affiliated with any party." But NBC's local Channel 26 station exposed her as the vice chair of the Republican Party in Kewaunee County from 2006-2008.

Grassfire is another nonprofit that supposedly grew out of "popular rage." But according to SourceWatch and Public Citizen, Grassfire is represented by the PR firm Shirley & Bannister. Craig Shirley was the man behind the infamous 1988 Willie Horton ad and the Stolen Honor movie that helped destroy John Kerry's presidential hopes. The firm, whose clients include Ann Coulter and the National Rifle Association, among others, denies the accusation.

Even Randall Terry, founder of infamous anti-abortion league Operation Rescue, is back in the so-called "freedom fight" with a new organization: Operation Rescue Insurrecta Nex, from which he sends e-mails to followers encouraging them to "Stir up some dust! Be 'unreasonable'!" and "be 'a little noisier than what you might normally be.'" At a press conference in July, Terry warned of "random acts of violence" if the Obama health-care plan passed, and violent "reprisals against those deemed guilty."

"Yes, yes, yes, absolutely," says Terry in a phone interview. "If the government of the United States forces people to pay for the murder of babies, there will be some people who will react. It's inevitable."

Never mind that the Obama health-care plan doesn't force anybody to perform or offer abortions.

Not all of the Christian right is on board with the effort to hijack the health-care debate. Frank Schaeffer, son of Francis Schaeffer (both credited by many scholars as ideological founders of the Christian right), is a vocal opponent of the recent townhall disruptions. He left the Republican party in 2000 and is now an independent who voted for Obama.

"The Glenn Becks of this world are literally responsible for unleashing what I regard as an anti-democratic, anti-American movement in this country that is trying to shut down legitimate debate and replace it with straight-out intimidation," said Schaeffer on MSNBC.

"These people are hatemongers and they're distributing their information on two levels: one, the lies about the health-care system, 'euthanasia' and all this nonsense, and on another level, leaving a loaded gun on the table, calling our president Hitler. They're shutting down these meetings and making debate impossible."

In their superb 2000 book, Right Wing Populism in America: Too Close for Comfort, Chip Berlet and Matthew N. Lyon make a case that these reactionary movements are nothing new, but the present link in a long history of organized mobs determined to shut down the opposing side.

"We have to distinguish between the people who are genuinely very angry because they're misinformed, and the people who are there trained to just disrupt," says Berlet. "Anger in a democratic society is commonplace and acceptable. Disruption is not."

What about guns at rallies? The loaded gun Schaeffer was talking about is no longer at the table, but right outside of Obama's town hall meetings.

"If a whole bunch of black people or undocumented aliens showed up with guns at a meeting of white elected officials, there would be a very different response," says Berlet.

"I've been an angry protester at meetings, but I haven't tried to shout people down," he adds. "I've protested outside, but I've never carried a gun. It's OK for people to be angry and ask questions, but not anger that is rage, that's bitter and nasty and vicious. Democrats and Republicans shouldn't make up information, but right now we see the Republicans and insurance companies making up information, and that's not acceptable. There is a difference between a legitimate angry question that expects an answer and staged confrontations with people so full of rage that they stop listening. That's not what democracy is about."

Scroll to read more Cleveland News articles
Join the Cleveland Scene Press Club

Local journalism is information. Information is power. And we believe everyone deserves access to accurate independent coverage of their community and state.
Help us keep this coverage going with a one-time donation or an ongoing membership pledge.


Join Cleveland Scene Newsletters

Subscribe now to get the latest news delivered right to your inbox.