There are bands, there are solo performers with bands, and then
there’s the Minus 5. They’re not so much a band as an ever-morphing
collective, spearheaded by Scott McCaughey (Young Fresh Fellows) and
his lieutenant Peter Buck (R.E.M.). This time, the company includes
members of the Decemberists, Norfolk & Western, Mendoza Line and
Posies, all bringing McCaughey’s sardonic story songs to luminous life.
There’s little of the droll power-pop of the Fellows — the
ambiance is closer to the rootsy, ornate lilt of Younger Than
Yesterday-era Byrds.
McCaughey’s gentle, kind-hearted singing evokes late-’60s Ray
Davies, and he writes songs like him too. Killingsworth brims
with vignettes rife with vivid detail and trenchant observations, borne
upon captivating, low-key, country-rock-flavored melodies. The winsome,
tragicomic “Big Beat Up Moon” is an overview of a neighborhood packed
with people dis-united by loneliness. “I Would Rather Sacrifice You” is
a heartfelt, gently rousing country-gospel song about a sanctimonious
Christian soldier ready and willing to destroy the world to save it (“I
spread the gospel with my gun”). Killingsworth is an
album geared toward two — or more — generations of rock;
get a copy for that friend enamored of early American Music Club and
Red House Painters and that parent or older sibling who still listens
to the Band and ’70s Randy Newman. — Mark Keresman
This article appears in Jul 8-14, 2009.
