Christopher O'Riley

Home to Oblivion: An Elliott Smith Tribute (World Village)

Christopher O'Riley Elliott Smith
All 185 of the "String Quartet Tributes to . . ." combined aren't worth the $15 a Christopher O'Riley tribute will run you. The pianist cut his teeth on Beethoven, Bach, and Stravinsky before moving on to the slightly less-lauded Radiohead. Now he's turned his classically trained digits to Elliott Smith, the erratic, addicted singer-songwriter whose apparent suicide gives his mopey lyrics a certain authenticity: He always got the worst of it, and he always felt like shit.

Unlike the subject of many a high-minded tribute, Smith actually used the instrument at hand. Stripped of his cries for help, the compositions still convey a fatal melancholy. But one of rock's dirty little secrets undercuts Home to Oblivion: Unless he's your designated musical martyr, a little Smith goes a long way. And as with his piano tributes to Radiohead, O'Riley avoids the songs you really want to hear. "Waltz #2 (XO)" is absent, and apparently the scales-like "Sweet Adeline" was too much of a slam-dunk for a Carnegie Hall kid. Or maybe -- in fact, let's hope -- the crossover jazz trio the Bad Plus called dibs on them.

Scroll to read more Music News articles


Join Cleveland Scene Newsletters

Subscribe now to get the latest news delivered right to your inbox.