I am heterosexual but get turned on watching male porn and in particular penises and what I would like to do with them. I’ve had a gay massage therapist massage me intimately and it was wonderful. I wanted to do more but am afraid of disease. I don’t feel bad about having him take care of me at all. I love women but they are difficult to find as true lovers.
What do you think of my feelings for men?
– Mike Anonymous
I have to say, there have been a lot of questions submitted lately about straight men and their interest in penises. Honestly, I’m glad people are asking. My hope is that more men give themselves permission to be curious about their sexuality without immediately judging what comes up.
So, keep it up, Cleveland! Mike, you deserve to explore these feelings without treating them like a problem that needs resolution. You are turned on by men, and you enjoyed an intimate experience with a man that left you wanting more. You also love women. As much as some deny bisexuality’s reality, those experiences can exist together. Your attraction to women does not cancel out your attraction to men, and enjoying a penis does not require you to immediately sit down and rewrite your entire autobiography.
One thing I talk about often as a sex therapist is the distinction between fantasy, behavior, and identity. What turns you on in porn does not automatically tell us how you identify or what you want to do in real life. I could watch a gang bang take place in porn and be turned on, when in reality that sounds exhausting.
However, you are describing more than a porn preference. You actually had an encounter with a dude, enjoyed it and wanted more of it. I would encourage you to give that experience some room instead of immediately trying to squeeze it into your current understanding of being heterosexual. There is no sexuality police department coming to revoke your “straight card,” but you are allowed to ask whether that label still tells the whole story.
As someone who identifies as gay, I never prescribe labels, but maybe bisexual is a word that could feel right. Now, before your brain starts doing the math, bisexuality does not require you to be equally attracted to men and women. You do not have to date a certain number of people or submit proof of purchase to qualify. You might want romantic relationships with women while also wanting sexual experiences with men. You might find that your interest in men extends further than you expected. You also might prefer to stay curious without choosing a label right now. What matters to me is whether you can be honest with yourself about what feels good and what you want.
I am curious, though: What do you mean when you say women are difficult to find as “true lovers”? Are you talking about finding someone who is emotionally available, or someone who shares your sexual interests? Do you mean someone who makes you feel wanted and takes an active interest in your pleasure? That phrase could mean very different things, and understanding what you feel is missing would help us make sense of what you are seeking. I also wonder whether being with this man gave you something you’ve struggled to ask for or receive with women, such as the freedom to relax and enjoy being touched without feeling pressure to perform. That is a question worth exploring, without assuming it explains away your attraction to men. Whatever “true lovers” means to you, I would be careful about turning disappointing experiences into a conclusion about women as a whole. We can fall into a trap when we say “all women” or “all men” are a certain way.
Now, let’s address your fear of disease, because taking care of your sexual health matters and the amount of misinformation out there makes me want to pull my hair out. The CDC estimated that approximately one in five people in the United States had an STI on any given day in 2018. That is a population-wide estimate, not a statistic exclusively about gay men. Having sex with a man does not automatically mean you will acquire a sexually transmitted infection, and having sex with a woman does not automatically protect you from one. A person’s sexual orientation is not an STI test result. The more useful questions involve what kinds of sexual contact you want and what precautions make sense. For example, oral sex carries little risk of HIV transmission, but other STIs can still be transmitted through oral sex. Condoms and other barriers can reduce the risk of several infections. Sex is inherently risky, always, no matter who you are having it with at the time.
I would encourage you to have a straightforward conversation with a sexual health provider about the contact you have already had and what you might want to explore. Be specific, because “intimate massage” leaves a lot open to interpretation. They can recommend appropriate testing and discuss whether PrEP makes sense for you. PrEP is medication that greatly reduces the chance of acquiring HIV, although it does not prevent other STIs. Sexual health conversations are part of taking care of yourself, and you deserve a provider who can have them without making you feel judged.
What stands out to me, Mike, is that you do not feel bad about what happened. That is a huge step! There is no need to go searching for shame just because you enjoyed something you did not expect. You also do not have to rush into another experience to figure yourself out.
It is 2026. Give yourself permission to wonder what you would enjoy with a man and whether that interest extends beyond sex. You can explore those questions at your own pace. Your sexuality does not have to become a crisis just because it has become a little more interesting.
The advice provided in this column is intended for general informational purposes only and should not be considered a substitute for professional therapy or mental health treatment. Each individual’s situation is unique, and the insights offered here may not address the complexities of your specific circumstances. If you’re experiencing challenges related to your mental health, relationships, or sexuality, I strongly encourage you to reach out to a licensed therapist or mental health professional for personalized support. You’re not alone—help is available.
Matt Lachman is a Licensed Professional Clinical Counselor and Supervisor, AASECT Certified Sex Therapist and owner of Cleveland Sex Therapy, located in Gordon Square. Since 2019, Matt has been promoting sex positivity and inclusivity in his work with individuals, couples and polyamorous relationships. When he’s not helping clients navigate their sexual and relational journeys, you can find him enjoying a cold brew at Gypsy Beans or watching reruns of Happy Endings. Ask a question here.
