Credit: Evan Zimmerman/Playhouse Square

The stage is no stranger to adaptations. This year alone, Playhouse Square has hosted a variety of shows based on books or films, including “Water for Elephants,” “The Outsiders,” “The Lion King,” “The Great Gatsby” and “Death Becomes Her.” Adaptations come with built-in audiences, but they also carry the risk of disappointing those same audiences if not translated properly. 

Now on stage at Playhouse Square, the touring production of “Clue” goes beyond merely paying homage to the campy, 1985 cult classic upon which it was based, following the film’s script so closely that you could practically refer to it as a transplant from screen to stage. While a faithful adaptation, it lacks innovation.  

“Clue” is inspired by the Hasbro board game of the same name, where players must solve a murder by correctly identifying a location, weapon and perpetrator. The story takes place in 1954 when six strangers are invited to dinner at the mansion of a Mr. Boddy. They are each greeted by Wadsworth, the butler, and each assigned a pseudonym: Colonel Mustard, Mrs. White, Mrs. Peacock, Mr. Green, Professor Plum and Miss Scarlet. After their mysterious host is murdered, mayhem ensues as the guests race to discover the guilty party before they’re victims themselves. 

Originally developed by Cleveland Play House, “Clue” began its first North American tour in February 2024. The non-Equity production under the direction of Casey Hushion began its tour in late 2025 and is now stopped for a short engagement at Playhouse Square.  

Part of the fun of theatrical adaptations is discovering how the creative team takes scenes painstakingly constructed on a page or skillfully spliced together on the cutting room floor and bring them to life with the limitations of live theater. So, what kind of theatrical magic do the artists of “Clue” deploy to tell this story uniquely?  

Because the narrative takes place throughout an expansive mansion, a clever set capable of portraying the many locales is crucial, and designer Lee Savage delivers. The basis of the set is the wood-paneled main hall and entryway to Mr. Boddy’s mansion. Like a pop-up book where tabs are pulled to reveal images, rooms of the house twirl into existence from either side of the stage or fly in from above. The characters “traverse” between the lushly outfitted rooms with the help of eerie and dramatic lighting shifts by designer Ryan O’Gara and playful original music by Michael Holland. 

While the set, lighting and orchestration are uniquely designed and creatively deployed, there is not much else that notably distinguishes the stageplay from the film. The show’s book was written by Sandy Rustin with additional material by Hunter Foster and Eric Price, but the dialogue so closely follows the screenplay by Jonathan Lynn that it feels close to a beat-for-beat recreation.  

Even though the script is identical in more ways than not, it does not mean the humor always lands. While the film’s jokes zip by, the play often leaves breathing room for laughter. There is a charm in the film’s quick wit that is lost in these pauses.  

The play is most successful when it employs physical, exaggerated gags, such as when the characters “run” from room to room, manipulate dead bodies or act out overly long death scenes. Live theater is a great vehicle for farce, but instead of leaning into physical absurdity and slapstick, “Clue” plays it safe and sticks to the original script. 

The characters are all caricatures that are played with a largeness that flinches at the thought of subtlety. Sarah Mackenzie Baron plays a monotone and morbid Mrs. White, a widower whose husbands have all passed mysteriously. Camille Capers as Miss Scarlet, the intelligent owner of a call girl service, is dripping with sensuality. In the role of Mrs. Peacock, a senator’s wife, is Madeline Raube, who exaggeratedly warbles through her lines. TJ Lamando’s Mr. Green, a man blackmailed for his homosexuality, is nasally, nerdy and bumbling. Played by Kyle Yampiro, Professor Plum, a therapist who slept with his patients, is sneering and sarcastic. Nate Curlott as Colonel Mustard, a general guilty of war profiteering, is dense to a groan-worthy degree.  

Playing the British butler, Wadsworth, is a talented Adam Brett. The iconic role was first originated by Tim Curry and Brett does a fine job emulating the frenzied, frantic servant who works double-time to solve the murder mystery. Dressed in a revealing maid’s outfit is Zoie Tannous as Yvette, who dons a thick French accent. In the roles of ancillary characters played equally as large are Kebron Woodfin as the Cop, AT Sanders as the Cook and Joseph Dalfonso as Mr. Boddy.  

If you’ve not seen the film, you’ll likely find the madcap energy of “Clue” entertaining. If you’re a fan of the film, you’ll likely enjoy the stage version thanks to its steadfast loyalty to the source material and its clever set design. But it’s impossible to ignore that “Clue” does not take any risks; it does not expand upon the original’s comedy and charm — it mostly regurgitates it. Granted, it’s a fun, campy regurgitation, but it might have you asking why you didn’t just stream the original for free on YouTube.  

“Clue” runs through Nov. 22, 2026, at Playhouse Square,1501 Euclid Avenue, Cleveland. Visit www.playhousesquare.org or call (216) 241-6000 for tickets, $36-115. 

Gwendolyn Kochur is an award-winning opinion writer who serves as the theater critic for Cleveland Scene. A 2019 graduate of Cleveland State University, she holds a degree in Journalism and Promotional Communication. Her experience spans arts journalism, marketing, and communications, including work with the Edinburgh Festival Fringe and BorderLight Theatre Festival. In addition to her writing, Gwendolyn serves as head of communications for a local arts nonprofit, bringing together her passion for storytelling, the performing arts, and arts advocacy.