Courtesy Old Brooklyn Community Development Corporation

When Connor Kloepfer and his girlfriend, Helen Andino, were looking to put down roots earlier this year, they saw Cleveland’s Old Brooklyn neighborhood as the “last frontier.”   

The two had met in Oregon, where Andino was in school and Kloepfer was working and putting on punk house-shows. When they were ready to settle down, the couple landed on Northeast Ohio, where Kloepfer grew up. Here was their best shot at homeownership.  

But once they arrived, Kloepfer realized buying in his hometown was harder than expected.   

“I had grown up in Lakewood but [had] been priced out,” Kloepfer, 28, said. “Which made me look for something more realistic.”  

Kloepfer and Andino scoured Cleveland’s West Side. Hailing from working-class backgrounds, both wanted somewhere down to earth while still maintaining the cultural vibrancy they found on the West Coast.  

Many houses required significant work and came with exorbitant prices. Once they came upon Old Brooklyn, however, they found what they were looking for: houses were affordable and close to business districts; neighbors were friendly and diverse, and the growing community had a strong sense of pride.  

“Old Brooklyn just encapsulates an authentic feel,” he said. “People from all backgrounds are just being.”  

Connor Kloepfer and Helen Andino in their Old Brooklyn home. Credit: Mark Oprea

They decided on a fixer-upper, a duplex. A home they could put a little work into and make their own for the long term, while also offering a quality rental unit downstairs. The neighborhood felt like a place where they could create a life.  

Kloepfer now frequents The Foundry Concert Club, which relocated to Old Brooklyn last year, whenever there’s a good punk show in town. Andino, a first-generation Honduran, feels at home in the neighborhood’s growing Latino community. Her favorite market is Tienda El Quetzal, a popular spot for traditional Latin American goods and fresh produce, which is within walking distance.  

To them, the neighborhood offers a mix that can be increasingly difficult to find: walkability, affordability and a strong sense of community.  

For several decades, Old Brooklyn saw little commercial or residential growth. But now, independent businesses—from coffee shops and vintage stores to art studios, restaurants and specialty retailers—are establishing themselves, while multiple development projects on the horizon are looking to bring new housing and commercial space to the neighborhood.  

These changes are calling attention to an area usually overlooked by local entrepreneurs and young homebuyers. One question remains: How can Old Brooklyn welcome new investment while preserving the affordability, charm and community that makes it great to begin with?  

For Ward 4 Councilman Kris Harsh, one of two council members who represent Old Brooklyn, the neighborhood’s changing landscape has been a long time coming.  

“A lot of seeds were sown in Old Brooklyn earlier this century,” Harsh, a longtime advocate for community development, said in an email.  

“There are so many people that have been pouring their passion into the community for years on top of that,” he added. “We are growing because the people that live here are taking ownership.”  

More than 32,000 people live in Old Brooklyn, making it Cleveland’s largest neighborhood. More than 70% of its homes are owner-occupied, according to Harsh — one of the highest rates in Cleveland. He sees that commitment by residents as central to the neighborhood’s growth.  

Old Brooklyn began as a rural farming community. The neighborhood played a major role in Greater Cleveland becoming known as the “Greenhouse Capital of America” with roughly 400 acres “under glass” by the early 1960s. Eventually, Old Brooklyn’s agricultural roots gave way to a more suburban landscape of mostly single-family homes and commercial corridors during its mid-20th-century heyday.  

Since then, the footprint of the neighborhood has stayed pretty much the same, while other Cleveland neighborhoods such as Ohio City, Tremont and Gordon Square have tried to reinvent themselves to meet changing tastes and expectations. In places like these, revitalization has come with a hefty barrier to entry, with median home prices for these three, on average, a quarter of a million dollars. In Old Brooklyn, they’re nearly half that.  

Today, as new developments bring some of that change south, could this be Old Brooklyn’s future?  

Formerly abandoned St. Luke’s Church at the corner of Memphis Avenue and Pearl Road. Credit: Mark Oprea

Old Brooklyn’s catalyst project is Memphis & Pearl, a more than $40 million, roughly 120,000-square-foot redevelopment at the corner of Memphis Avenue and Pearl Road. The project is poised to restore the formerly abandoned St. Luke’s Church for commercial use, while adding 80-plus apartments in a mixed-use property on the site of the former Greenline Building.  

“This neighborhood has not seen investment like this in 75 years,” Jim Ambrose, president of the project’s developer Tipping Point Real Estate Development, told Ideastream Public Media last year.  

The project initially faced community pushback when proposed in 2021, as many felt St. Luke’s should be preserved rather than destroyed. But after revisions that maintained more of the historic church’s original footprint, the plan gained greater support from residents.  

According to Harsh, the project has already spurred investment in the surrounding area over the past two years. One includes plans by Greenlight Building Co. to build six new market-rate town houses on a vacant lot in the 3500 block of Stanford Avenue, just west of Old Brooklyn’s main drag.  

However, with a starting price of $375,000 for up to 1,675 square feet, the townhouses would enter the market at a significantly higher price point than the neighborhood’s median home sale price of $161,000. A number up by 36% from 2021, according to the Old Brooklyn Community Development Corporation.  

The price gap raises a difficult question: What happens when development intended to breathe new life into a neighborhood makes it harder for longtime residents to stay?  

Much of the development in the area has focused on upgrading existing infrastructure rather than building new, said OBCDC executive director and neighborhood resident David Robinson. According to him, they’ve secured over $700,000 worth of investments in the last two years solely for existing infrastructure.  

“We’re not necessarily tearing down a lot of things, trying to erase neighborhood fabric or neighborhood history,” he explained. “We’re really trying to revitalize what’s already there.”  


Left to right: Amber Atkinson, owner of Kindrid Kava. Marina Racquel Fleeman, of Foxy Fur Grooming. Holly Franklin Buchbinder, of HFB Ceramics. Bizzy Blank and Meghan Paris-Blank, co-owners of Shag Vintage.  Credit: Mark Oprea

This approach is one that has been apparent to Meghan Paris-Blank, an Old Brooklyn resident of more than 15 years. When South Hills Antique Gallery, which spent over 40 years at 2010 West Schaaf Road, came up for sale last year, she and her wife, Bizzy Blank, saw an opportunity to preserve a piece of the neighborhood while giving it a new life. They bought the shop and reopened it as Shag Vintage.  

“I was afraid that [Old Brooklyn] would get gentrified, like a Tremont situation or an Ohio City situation,” said Paris-Blank.  

Rather than gentrification, she says she feels the neighborhood is being revitalized.  

Beyond development, Paris-Blank says she has watched the neighborhood become more diverse. According to a 2018 community health study by the OBCDC identified the neighborhood as the fastest growing area for African American residents, and the fastest growing community for Hispanics in the Northeast Ohio region; the latter demographic having more than doubled in population size since 2000.  

But as the neighborhood has changed, Paris-Blank says it has maintained the sense of community she feels is integral to its fabric.   

“The neighborhood was really welcoming and embraced us when we started,” she said. The couple feels that if they ever needed anything, as a resident or business owner, she said, a neighbor “would be there to help.”  

Shag Vintage isn’t the only new business in the area. According to OBCDC, seven businesses opened in the past year, and there are more on the way.  

“I’ve always [said] it’s the next big thing,” said Rachel Ventura, long-time OB resident and owner of FrankieLynn Hot Dogs with her husband, Lloyd Foust.   

Ventura said the neighborhood has seen a lot of change over the past decade, pointing to the opening of Sixth City Cycles in 2018 and several coffee shops as examples.  

“Things that weren’t here 15 years ago are now within walking distance of a lot of us,” she said.  

The couple’s hot dog cart has become a familiar presence at the neighborhood farmers market and annual street festival; two newer community events that have quickly gained popularity.   

Recently, FrankieLynn’s announced that it will be opening its first brick and motor shop in early 2027. Ventura and Foust hope to serve their gourmet hot dogs alongside other local goods. The community’s reaction to this has been palpable, with Ventura saying they often have people dropping by to tell them how excited they are to have them open in the neighborhood.  

Both current residents of Old Brooklyn and entrepreneurs from other neighborhoods are being drawn to the area by its character and opportunity, but one thing is clear: “It’s not like someone’s running here and just trying to slam a Chipotle somewhere,” said Foust.  

In August, Dahlia Coffee Co. opened its second Cleveland location in Old Brooklyn.  

“Old Brooklyn has always caught my attention because it feels like a tight-knit community,” said Dahlia owner Natalia Alcazar. “When the building became available, I knew it was my opportunity to bring light to that corner again.”   

She knew that the building itself held a lot of memories for the residents of Old Brooklyn and said she was honored to be able to re-activate it.  

When Dan Watson and business partner Eric Ho opened Never Say Dive on Broadview Road nearly three years ago, its food and cocktail menu offered something relatively uncommon: a “Hi-Lo” cocktail bar that could serve $3 lagers as easily as it could $60 caviar service. This blend of approaches has earned acclaim from the dining community, including earning the restaurant spots on local best restaurant lists.   

Now, as more businesses open and development moves forward, he’s optimistic about where Old Brooklyn is headed.  

“It’s just turned into this cool area,” said Watson. “It feels like it’s becoming the neighborhood where more and more and more people are moving to right now.”  

He said that the city has done a good job at infusing funds into the neighborhood, allowing businesses to update storefronts and create “white boxes”, or blank slates, resulting in an influx of new concepts.  

Other recent additions to the neighborhood include HFB Ceramics Studio for ceramic wares and art lessons; Kindrid Kava for botanicals and coffee; Melted Wings Winery for wine and charcuterie; The Witch Doctor for occult-themed cocktails; and Greek Corner Gyro for gyros and authentic baklava – to name a few.  

Additions such as these continue to convince Kloepfer and Andino that they made the right decision to buy in the area.  

Since moving in September, they’ve slowly begun making their house feel like home, day by day, they said. It’s a kind of metaphor for Old Brooklyn, you could say. Shop vacs and cans of paint share space with guitar amps and Andino’s kitchen art studio. The old creating space for the new.   

“It’s a slow burn,” Kloepfer said about the renovations, especially while balancing the renovations with work and everyday life.   

But the goal was never to finish everything at once. The goal was to find a place to invest in, a place to call home, and a neighborhood to embrace, even as it changes. 

Follow us: Google News | NewsBreak | Reddit | Instagram | Facebook | Twitter