The Expressway Diner closed in 2009 after a too-brief run of just five years. In fact, the property has sat fallow for longer than it was open. That will change in the next few weeks as The City Diner (5109 Memphis Ave., 216-400-7529) prepares to open its doors after months of renovations and improvements at the hands of new owner Edward Michalski.

“It’s been a labor of love,” Michalski says of the work. “The improvements have been mostly F,F and E – furniture, fixtures and equipment. We updated the restrooms, added new paint, décor, lighting and kitchen equipment.”

Michalski, a chef with largely corporate experience at busy spots like the Horseshoe Casino, Progressive Field and the MGM, says he was smitten with the property and its potential the moment he laid eyes on it.

“The building was so beautiful I actually stopped the car and couldn’t believe my eyes,” he says. “A turnkey operation in a stainless steel diner; there’s not too many of these left.”

Less than a mile from the Cleveland Metroparks Zoo and about five miles south of Public Square, the diner’s location in Old Brooklyn also immediately appealed to Michalski.

“My father is from Old Brooklyn, my grandfather had a butcher shop here for 40 years, my grandmother taught piano here, so I’m definitely very proud and honored to have this opportunity,” he explains.

When the City Diner opens it will offer “classic diner cuisine built on a culinary foundation.” A lengthy all-day breakfast menu features platters like the Old Brooklyn Special with three eggs, sausage or bacon, potato hash, warm apple sauce and toast. There’s also corned beef hash with housemade corned beef, two eggs and Swiss, a chorizo, cheese and black bean omelet, classic eggs Benedict, and Belgium waffles topped with fresh strawberries and vanilla whipped cream. On Sundays, the diner will offer an all-you-can-eat breakfast buffet.

The lunch and dinner menu offers soups of the day (roasted chicken noodle, creamy tomato, Southwest black bean, cheddar-ale bisque), Chef and Cobb salads, burgers with house-cut fries, triple-decker Club sandwiches, and City Mains built around hearty comfort foods like roasted chicken pot pie, short rib stroganoff, Yankee pot roast and meatloaf.

Breakfast items hover in the $7 to $9 range, while lunch and dinner plates edge up to the $8 to $15 range. The most expensive item on the menu is a 12-ounce Certified Angus Beef ribeye with vegetables and roasted garlic mashed potatoes for $19.

“We only use fresh vegetables, real mashed potatoes and hand-cut fries,” says the chef. “The fish and steaks are cut by hand, sauces and dressings are from scratch, stocks made from bones, and we hand-dip our milkshakes, malts and floats.”

Michalski adds that they even brought on a baker to make pastries. He also is working with and showcasing products from neighborhood assets like Mazzone & Sons Bakery, Lou’s Sausage, Cake Royale and others.

Look for the City Diner to open in late July or early August.

This article appears in Jul 12-18, 2017.

For 25 years, Douglas Trattner has worked as a full-time freelance writer, editor and author. His work as co-author on Michael Symon's cookbooks have earned him four New York Times Best-Selling Author honors, while his longstanding role as Scene dining editor has garnered awards of its own.

6 replies on “Coming Soon: The City Diner in Old Brooklyn”

  1. Lou’s Sausage is not a “neighborhood asset”. It’s on Miles Ave in the Lee-Miles neighborhood, 8 miles away. They should have used neighborhood asset The Sausage Shoppe, that’s actually 6 blocks away from them.
    Mazzone & Sons is not a “neighborhood asset” either. They’re in the Clark-Fulton neighborhood, 3 miles away. They should have used neighborhood assets Memphis Bakery or Michael’s bakery that are actaully in the neighborhood, just blocks from them.
    Michalski shouldn’t say he’s using neighborhood assets when they aren’t in the neighboorhood.

  2. HiGood Evening Sir or Madam,

    I appreciate your review and comments of the article. I agree the word choice of “neighborhood assest” is incorrect as to the location of some of the vendors listed.

    As the owner, we take pride in everything that we do. From our inception and early business planning we have thought of OB and people and business that make community. The City Diners OB business parnters include but not limited to: Cake Royal, JAC Creative, Witmer Refrigeration and Vicki Vincent designs.

    We welcome any potential vendor to drop by, make a business connection and showcase their products/goods/services.

    I think it is important to note that we also have created over 45 opening hourly Team Members positions. We filled the vast majority of those postions directly from Old Brooklyn.

    I hope this illuminates our commitments and validates our actions.

    Thank you again,

    Edward Michalski
    Owner
    The City Diner
    Great Food, Great City

  3. The expressway diner had good food, good prices and good portion, but their problems were servers, parking, letting employees sit out in front with customers and management. I have worked in the food industry since I was 10. I know what it takes and how to get it done. It does not matter how good the food is or the prices if all the little things are not also taken care of. I wish you all the best and look forward to dining at your establishment.

  4. I wish Mr. Michalski the very best success! The location is in a great area in Old Brooklyn and there are lots of great folks around that area. It is great to see that the property has been updated and will no longer be vacant. Kudos to the owner and staff!!!

  5. Cannot wait Stella assures me I will not be disappointed . She is a great PR person and friend !

Comments are closed.