- CLEVELAND POLICE
- McGonegal
The Rev. James McGonegal of St. Ignatius of Antioch Church pleaded guilty this morning to soliciting sex from a Cleveland Metroparks ranger and omitting the fact that he was HIV-positive.
(Read the original story below.)
McGonegal will now participate in an early intervention program, per a plea deal that’s been in the works for months. If he completes with program, he will avoid a felony conviction and get all record of this crime expunged.
Needless to say, the plea deal also bans McGonegal from all Cleveland Metroparks property.
***
Originally published Oct. 15, 2013
The Rev. James McGonegal of St. Ignatius of Antioch Church will appear in court this morning after exposing himself and then some in the Cleveland Metroparks Oct. 11.
McGonegal pulled into the Edgewater Park parking lot, and a plain-clothes park ranger happened to be in the area. The ranger was leaving the parking lot and about to head down the trail head, but McGonegal had rolled down his window and begun tapping on the door frame. He was gesturing toward the ranger.
As the report goes on, the ranger continued walking out of sight, but then stopped and headed back to figure out what was going on. As he returned to the SUV, McGonegal was pulling out of his spot, but then quickly shifted back into it when he saw the ranger approaching.
The two got into conversation, with McGonegal explaining that he wanted “to get off,” and that he’d pay $50. The ranger questioned him and soon asked to “see it.” McGonegal then exposed himself to the ranger and began masturbating in his car. The ranger explained who we was and promptly arrested the priest.
A search of the car turned up three cock rings and a bottle labeled “Pig Sweat.” It was nail polish remover, which McGonegal huffed to “get a buzz.” The bottle had an image of a “pig/man figure wearing buttocks-free chaps,” as the report explains.
The Cleveland Catholic Diocese released their statement Friday night: “Diocesan authorities have a policy of cooperating with civil authorities in these kinds of matters, and will do so in this matter.”
According to those close to the Cleveland Catholic Diocese, McGonegal’s sexual orientation was basically an open secret around town, though it’s unclear if the Diocese or fellow priests knew that he was HIV positive.
This article appears in Oct 9-15, 2013.

Pig Sweat sales are soaring.
What this guy has done to both the Catholic Church and Gays is despicable. ONE BAD APPLE don’t spoil the whole bunch. He needs to get out of his parish in shame.
smh.
so the guy did not disobey the direction of a police officer and exposed himself…the whole thing is a waste of tax payer money. They then UPPED the charges just because the guy was HIV+ ??? How discriminatory. Ohio sucks ass!!! If it were a straight couple this would not happen
Stupid people and their comments make me laugh, lol.
Father Lurch looks like a special guy.
As the 21st century dawned, HIV was no longer a “death sentence”. I certainly condemn Lurch’s violation of his vows as a priest, but really, what is up with this hysteria about gay men having sex in the park?
There are no 6 year olds in the parks at night, unaccompanied by a parent (I hope).
What is so freaking scarey about people who like to have casual sex out of doors? I’ve done it. I bet most adults have.
My name is Shantell Omen, i am from England, i am 35 years old and i have been married for 6 years, last year i was having some changes in my body which got me scared, i had to see my doctor to know whats going on, so when i saw the my doctor, i was shocked with the awful news which i was told, i was told that i am a HIV positive, i was so cold, confused and don’t know where to start from, suddenly tears drop from my eyes because i know i have not slept another man only my husband, i went home and could not say a word to anyone for on week, i locked myself, i could not do anything, until one morning i called my husband and i had a word with him and i told him what i discovered then he confessed to me that he had unprotected sex with a lady and he never knew the lady had the virus and he too never knew he has been infected also, i was mad at him but there was nothing i could do because the did has been done, i began to search for help from different places praying to God bring me a healer and behold God answered my prayer, i one Sunday morning i was going through a site where i saw a comment of a lady who had HIV for 6 years and was healed by (Dr.robinsonbuckler@)(yahoo.)com and i had to contact this man to cure me from this deadly virus and a week later God answered my prayer, i and my husband was healed from the same Dr.Robinson buckler since then i am back to my feet and my life is moving smoothly again, i cant stop giving my testimony, and i can stop praising this man for restoring my life.
I was diagnosed with HIV this year, and for some reason my mind was ready for that answer since I had been showing strange signs since January of this year. Both my love were there with me when I got the news and we are both very supportive, and I am truly thankful for that. I told my closest friends, one of them being the girl I really like, and she has been supporting me since I started this whole process and has always given me support. So far no one has turned their back on me due to ignorance or anything like that. I am thankful that I have not fallen into a depression or anything like that. On Monday August I get my result for CD4 (T-cell) count and virus load count, and I am hoping I have a high level of T-cells. The last thing I have lost is hope and that was what lead me to Dr Odia of ( drodiaherbalistcenter @ gmail . com ) Who helped me with herbal herbs medicine to get me cured of this disease, and I would like to let others know that even though sometimes we might feel the world is going to come down on us, there will always be someone we can count on, who will support us and love us. I am not in a support group at the moment but I would love to be in one, meet others and shere with thm my testimony. This is not the end of the world; this is not a reason to give up on our hopes and dreams. We are in control, not the disease. Contact him:( drodiaherbalistcenter @ gmail . com ) as I am right now, I am grateful.
As much as i would like to advice and give my testimony how i resolve my marriage problems, typing a long text wouldn’t help me tell the truth better so i would just be straight forward in what i have to say.First love spell are real second if you are to contact any spell caster be very careful so as not to contact the wrong one as at now the only one i would recommend is Ajayi Ololo.He helped me with my marriage problem and some other thing i needed to be fixed can really give details here.At a time it was hard to trust him because he asked for material i had to pay for or produce as wrong as i was,i thought he was reaping me off my money as the non-real and fake spell caster did.Just when i thought to say no more he finished what i had asked him to do for me. I felt humiliated for not trusting him at first.For me i can say he is real and if you ever contact him have no fear you’re safe with him because he can fix the longest broken relationship you can see other testimony online if you are skeptical about mine.His contact email is ajayiololo@yahoo. com